NYC March Madness Catering

March Madness Catering New York City

March in New York is a hinge moment between seasons. Winter loosens its grip, daylight stretches longer, and the city’s attention briefly shifts from boardrooms and reservations to basketball brackets taped to office walls. In that atmosphere, many hosts feel pulled between two instincts: they want the energy of a watch party, but they also want the polish that reflects real New York taste. Susan’s Kitchen Catering and Events sits squarely in that space, delivering food and service that feel elevated without feeling formal, celebratory without feeling chaotic, and unmistakably rooted in local, seasonal ingredients. Our approach treats March Madness not as a gimmick, but as another occasion that deserves thought, care, and culinary integrity.

We don’t view March Madness as a reason to lower standards or rely on mass-produced party trays. Instead, we reinterpret familiar flavors through a refined, chef-driven lens that aligns with how we build menus year-round. Our culinary team works with regional farms, greenmarkets, and trusted purveyors to source produce, meats, and dairy that are at their peak in early spring. That same seasonal discipline guides our broader programs, similar to the philosophy behind our seasonal holiday catering, where timing, provenance, and craftsmanship shape every dish. The result is food that feels both comforting and current—recognizable enough for a watch party, but sophisticated enough for discerning New York guests.

MARCH MADNESS CATERING NYC MENU

All prices are per guest · 10-guest minimum
Orders require at least 24 hours’ notice

BEEF

$42.00 per dozen

• Mini Corn Dog Muffins
• Meatball Sub Skewers with Marinara
• Raspberry Chipotle Meatballs
• Swedish Meatballs with Teriyaki Sauce
• Mini Italian Meatball Skewers with Marsala Sauce
• Beef Empanadas with Salsa Verde
• Beef Taco Cups with Salsa Mexicana
• Baked BBQ Beef Taquitos with Sour Cream and Guacamole
• Cheesesteak Egg Rolls with Ketchup and Mustard
• Corn Dogs with Mustard
• Sweet & Spicy Root Beer BBQ Beef Sliders
• Pigs in a Blanket with Mustard
• Mini Cheeseburgers on Brioche Buns

VEGETARIAN $39.00 per dozen

• Broccoli & Cheddar Quinoa Bites
• Potato Skins with Melted Cheese
• Chili Lime Nacho Mozzarella Sticks
• Blue Cheese & Guacamole Stuffed Mushrooms
• Pastry Jalapeño Poppers
• Taco Salad Mini Cups
• Jalapeño Poppers
• Avocado Egg Rolls with Cilantro Lime Sauce
• Spinach Pizza Squares with Marinara
• Individual Seven-Layer Dips
• Sage & Asiago Polenta Rounds with Wild Mushrooms

CHICKEN $41.00 per dozen

• Buffalo Chicken Cheese Balls with Hot Sauce
• Football-Style Deviled Eggs
• Apple Chicken Meatballs with Honey Mustard
• Shredded Buffalo Chicken Sliders
• Buffalo Chicken Wings
• Chicken Taco Cups
• Buffalo Chicken Taquitos with Salsa Mexicana
• Chipotle Popcorn Chicken with Chipotle Sauce
• Mini Chicken Quesadillas with Queso Blanco & Three-Pepper Salsa
• Brazilian Coconut Chicken with Honey Mango Sauce
• Macadamia-Crusted Chicken with Honey Mustard

PORK $42.00 per dozen

• Loaded Baked Potato Bites with Cheddar & Bacon
• Mini Deep-Dish Pepperoni Pizzas
• Bacon Tater Tot Bombs
• Pepperoni Pizza Puffs
• Sweet & Spicy Chicken Bites Wrapped in Bacon

SEAFOOD $42.00 per dozen

• Grilled Jerk Shrimp & Pineapple Skewers
• New England Crab Cake Bites with Citrus Caper Rémoulade
• Crispy Coconut Shrimp Skewers with Piña Colada Sauce
• Avocado, Olive, Tomato, Onion & Feta Cups

MARCH MADNESS CATERING NYC

Displayed Platters, Dips & Snacks

CHEESE & CRACKERS — $14.95 per guest
Imported and domestic cheeses with grapes, berries, roasted walnuts, crackers, and baguette slices

CRUDITÉS & DIPS — $9.95 per guest
Seasonal vegetables served with two house-made dips

HAPPY HOUR — $24.95 per guest
• Plantain chips with guacamole & tropical salsa
• Chicken, vegetable & shrimp quesadilla sampler
• Pigs in a blanket with ketchup & honey mustard

AFTERNOON SNACKS — $24.95 per guest
• Buffalo wings with celery, carrots & ranch
• Potato chips with onion dip
• Mozzarella sticks with marinara

MEDITERRANEAN DIPS & CHIPS — $13.95 per guest
Hummus, baba ghanoush, tahini, spinach yogurt & pita chips

SOUTHERN DIPS & CHIPS — $16.95 per guest
Nacho cheese, salsa, guacamole, sour cream, chipotle cream & tortilla chips

SNACK MIX — $13.95 per guest
Terra chips, nachos & pretzels with salsa and guacamole

ASSORTED MIXED NUTS — $9.95 per guest
Cashews, pistachios, almonds, Brazil nuts, filberts & pecans

THE SLAM DUNK — $25.95 per guest
Mini burritos, chicken empanadas & beef tacos with salsa and guacamole

Festive & Interactive Bars

All prices are per guest · 10-guest minimum

MEXICAN FAJITA BAR — $36.95 per guest

• Grilled Steak & Chicken Fajitas
• Spanish Rice & Refried Beans
• Corn & Flour Tortillas, Corn Chips
• Lettuce, Tomatoes, Guacamole, Salsa, Sour Cream, Pico de Gallo
• Shredded Cheese
• Sliced Fruit
• Cookies & Brownies

BURGER BAR — $32.95 per guest

• Black Angus Beef, Turkey & Veggie Burgers
• French Fries & Sweet Potato Fries
• Lettuce, Tomato, Onion, Pickles, Buns & Condiments
• Coleslaw
• Sliced Fruit
• Dessert Platter

HOT DOG BAR — $21.95 per guest

• Beef & Veggie Hot Dogs
• Soft Potato Buns
• Coleslaw, Chips & Potato Salad
• Relish, Ketchup, Mustard, Onions, Tomatoes

CHILI BAR — $33.95 per guest

• Pasta, Rice, Tortillas, Hot Dogs
• French Fries, Fritos & Baked Potatoes
• Cheese, Sour Cream, Onions, Jalapeños & Tomatoes

SOUTHERN FEAST — $39.95 per guest

• Chili with Cheddar, Sour Cream & Onions
• Buffalo Wings with Ranch & Celery
• BBQ St. Louis Ribs
• Iceberg Wedges with Blue Cheese Dressing
• Seven-Layer Dip with Tortilla Chips
• Cookies & Brownie Bites

MARCH MADNESS DESSERTS

All prices are per guest · 10-guest minimum

COOKIES — $8.95 per guest
Assorted house-baked themed cookies

CUPCAKES — $9.95 per guest
Assorted themed cupcakes

SLICED FRUIT — $9.95 per guest
Seasonal fruit display with cottage cheese dip

Seamless Drop-Off for Real NYC Living

New York hosting often happens in spaces that are beautiful but logistically complex: prewar elevators, doorman buildings, loft freight entrances, and tight kitchen layouts. Our drop-off catering is designed specifically for that reality. We deliver neatly organized, temperature-stable food that arrives ready to serve, eliminating last-minute stress for the host. Everything is labeled, thoughtfully arranged, and packaged with an eye toward both presentation and sustainability. This quiet precision mirrors the care we bring to more observant occasions like our Good Friday catering menu, where timing, restraint, and respect for tradition are essential—qualities that translate naturally into a well-run March Madness gathering.

Whether your watch party takes place in a Midtown conference room, a Tribeca loft, or a townhouse on the Upper West Side, our catering is designed to integrate smoothly into your environment. We understand building protocols, delivery windows, and the importance of punctuality in a city where schedules are tight. Many of our clients first work with us for celebratory milestones—such as Christmas catering in NYC—and return for occasions like March Madness because they trust our reliability and professionalism. That consistency is what allows hosts to focus on their guests rather than worrying about logistics.

Seasonality Shapes Every Detail

Early spring subtly influences everything we create: brighter flavors, lighter textures, and cleaner presentations that feel fresh after winter’s richness. We prioritize local herbs, tender greens, citrus, and responsibly sourced proteins, balancing indulgence with vibrancy so the food remains satisfying throughout multiple games. This same sensitivity to season and tradition informs larger family-centered celebrations such as our Thanksgiving catering services, where depth of flavor and careful preparation matter just as much as they do at an upscale watch party. For March Madness, that translates into food that feels lively, layered, and intentional rather than heavy or monotonous.

We design catering that welcomes every guest at the table. Dietary preferences—vegan, gluten-free, or kosher-style—are integrated from the start rather than treated as add-ons. Our experience across culturally significant events, including kosher-style Passover options and Easter Sunday event catering, has sharpened our ability to balance tradition, accessibility, and elegance. That expertise benefits any March Madness gathering with a diverse guest list, ensuring no one feels overlooked and every dish feels complete.

A Quietly Elevated Watch Party

The most memorable March Madness events don’t feel overproduced or flashy. They feel comfortable, curated, and effortlessly polished. Susan’s Kitchen supports that tone by handling the details behind the scenes—delivery timing, presentation, portion flow, and setup—so hosts can actually enjoy the games. This same sensibility appears in our festive programs like St. Patrick’s Day catering, where celebration meets refinement. For March Madness, that means vibrant food, calm service, and an atmosphere that feels both social and sophisticated.

Sustainability is woven into our work, not added as a marketing angle. We prioritize locally sourced ingredients, thoughtful portion planning, and packaging that minimizes waste wherever possible. Compostable or recyclable materials are used when appropriate, and we work to reduce unnecessary plastics in our delivery process. Even for a lively sports watch party, we believe responsible catering matters. High-quality food should support both your guests and the environment, and our practices reflect that commitment in every order.

Why NYC Hosts Choose Susan’s Kitchen

Our reputation rests on reliability, discretion, and culinary excellence. Clients trust us because the food tastes as good as it looks, arrives exactly when promised, and reflects the character of their event rather than overpowering it. Whether the occasion is a private dinner, a corporate reception, a major holiday, or a March Madness watch party, we bring the same respect for ingredients, attention to detail, and calm professionalism. In a city where hosting can feel complicated, we make it feel seamless.