Halloween Catering Menu for a Spooktacular NYC Party

Halloween in New York is more than trick-or-treating. It’s a full-on season of costumed celebrations, themed office events, rooftop parties, and family gatherings. And whether you’re planning an eerie evening affair or a playful afternoon with coworkers, food plays a starring role in setting the mood.

At Susan’s Kitchen, we embrace the fun of Halloween with a catering menu that’s as festive as it is flavorful. Forget bland buffets or store-bought trays—our Halloween catering menu brings character and creativity to your table, transforming the ordinary into a feast that’s a little spooky, a little silly, and a lot satisfying.

Here’s a taste of what we’re serving this Halloween season.

Spooktacular Halloween Catering Menu

Get ready to thrill your guests with Susan’s Kitchen’s hauntingly delicious Halloween catering menu. Whether you’re hosting a spooky soirée or a family-friendly gathering, our menu is designed to enchant and delight with every bite.

From ghoulish appetizers to decadent desserts, we offer a full range of themed dishes that capture the essence of Halloween. Our expert chefs craft each dish with creativity and flair, ensuring your event is both memorable and frightfully fun.

Let us handle the culinary magic while you enjoy the festivities. Explore our menu and discover how we can make your Halloween event a scream!

Cold Appetizers ($44.00 per dozen)

Monster Eyes! Deviled Eggs – Traditional with fresh herbs
Assorted mini–focaccia sandwiches: Witch Diamonds
Celery and carrot sticks with peanut butter & ranch dressing
Cubed cheddar cheese with crackers
Salami and cheese skewers
Olive puffs with green olives

Hot Appetizers ($44.00 per dozen)

Bloody Fingers – Chicken strips with marinara dipping sauce
BBQ Bat Wings – Chicken wings served with ranch dressing
Haunted Dogs – Pastry-wrapped franks
Mini meatball skewers with masala sauce
Mac and cheese pops
Black bean roll-ups with sour cream and salsa
Gourmet mini burgers with tomato, blue cheese, and Thousand Island dressing, topped with a cocktail pickle
Mini quiche – vegetarian or Lorraine
Traditional deviled eggs
Mini burgers with full fixings: lettuce, tomato, pickles, cheeses, sauces
BBQ pork mini sandwiches
Bacon-wrapped water chestnut rolls

Halloween Platters

7 Layer Dip – $9.95 per person
Trio of Spreads (hummus, spinach dip, roasted red pepper hummus) – $6.95 per person
Tortilla chips with salsa – $7.95 per person
Chopped fruit bowl – $4.95 per person
Carrot and celery sticks with ranch or blue cheese – $5.95 per person

Sweets

Gourmet Halloween sugar cookies – $4.50 per person
Mini Halloween cupcakes – $5.50 per person
Pumpkin pie (10 inches) – $38.00
Sugar-spiced almonds – $9.95 per person
Dirt with worms – $6.95 per person
Apple dip with spooky crisps – $5.95 per person
Honey chip granola bars – $6.95 per person
Three-in-one popcorn crunch with peanuts, popcorn, and candy corn – $4.95 per person

Beverages ($6.95 per person)

Black Halloween Punch
Spooky Citrus Punch

Hot Boof-fet ($38.95 per person)

Rosemary plum roast pork
Chicken medallions with capers, mushrooms, and chardonnay reduction
Russian beef stroganoff with wild mushrooms
Green beans with basil
Scaredy rice with black beans and diced carrots
Ginger squash soup
Sweet potato casserole with mushrooms
Cornbread muffins
Crunchy apple salad with raisins, celery, and walnuts
Includes your choice of one sweet from the dessert list

To explore more seasonal ideas beyond Halloween, take a look at our seasonal event catering menus crafted for holidays all year round.

Perfect for NYC Office Parties and Family Gatherings

Halloween events in New York often fall into two categories—cleverly decorated office parties and family-friendly neighborhood get-togethers. In both settings, a themed catering spread can turn a casual gathering into a memorable experience. With our Spooktacular Halloween Catering Menu, you don’t need to spend hours prepping in the kitchen or buying last-minute supplies. We bring the flavor, the fun, and the fright—all in one delivery.

For companies looking to boost morale or celebrate the season in style, our office-ready food packages transition effortlessly from lunch meetings to festive holiday events. Think playful dishes like “Bloody Fingers” chicken strips and “Dirt with Worms” pudding—served with polish and a wink of Halloween mischief.

Planning something at home? The wide range of options makes it easy to build a menu that’s both kid-friendly and adult-approved. Deviled eggs and mac and cheese pops satisfy the younger crowd, while our gourmet mini burgers, rosemary plum roast pork, and themed desserts impress parents and guests alike.

Flavors That Celebrate the Season

Halloween may be spooky, but the food should be comforting and delicious. This menu brings in warm fall ingredients like squash, sweet potatoes, apples, and cinnamon in both savory and sweet forms. Dishes like ginger squash soup and sweet potato casserole add depth and color to the table, making the spread feel rooted in the season while still embracing the theme.

If you’re looking for more hearty, autumn-inspired ideas, check out our hearty fall-friendly dishes built around rich, satisfying flavors. They pair beautifully with Halloween’s darker aesthetic and can be mixed into the same event for added variety.

Tips for a Smooth Halloween Catering Experience

October is a busy month in NYC, especially as Halloween approaches. We recommend placing your order at least a week in advance to guarantee availability and timing. Our team can help you build a menu that suits your group size, venue, and dietary needs. Want a little extra magic? Add spooky labels to the dishes, or incorporate dry ice and flickering candles for atmospheric effect.

Some hosts like to borrow ideas from other holidays and blend them into their Halloween celebrations. For example, elements from our romantic holiday catering ideas can add a touch of elegance to an otherwise creepy setup. Others turn to our festive catering themes with spice to add a kick of flavor to their Halloween table.

Celebrate with Ease

With so many details to manage during Halloween, from costumes to decor to entertainment, catering shouldn’t be one of the stress points. Susan’s Kitchen brings years of experience in New York’s fast-paced event scene, making us a trusted partner for holiday gatherings of any size.

Looking ahead to November and beyond? Browse our elegant seasonal brunch menus or consider how our patriotic menus with bold flavors can inspire your next themed gathering.

Whether you’re throwing a haunted happy hour, a costume contest at the office, or a laid-back dinner party with friends, our Halloween catering delivers everything you need—flavor, fun, and a little fright.